Search Within: Dashboard Live TV Shared Links Twitter Videos News Blogs Forums

The Rachel Maddow Show

MSNBC

Aired on Monday, Feb 08, 2010 (2/8/2010) at 07:00 PM

Transcript

00:00:00Im before he can be convicted?
00:00:04Do you consider yourself qualified to vote in this country?
00:00:06Can you answer that question?
00:00:07Want to hear it again?
00:00:09If a person is charged with treason and denies his guilt, how many persons must testify against him before he can be convicted?
00:00:18How about this one from the same test?
00:00:21In what year did the congress gain the right to prohibit the migration of persons to the states?
00:00:27Do you know the answer to that one?
00:00:30Again, these are from alabama's literacy test in 1965.
00:00:35It was applied selectively of course to black voters to keep them from registering.
00:00:40If you lived in georgia in 1958, you would have faced questions like this one.
00:00:44Who is the solicitor general of the state judicial circuit in which you live and who is the judge of such circuit?
00:00:50If such circuit has more than one judge, name them all.
00:00:53How did you do on that one?
00:00:54How about this one?
00:00:55What does the constitution of georgia provide regarding the suspension of the writ of habeas corpus?
00:01:01If you wanted to vote in georgia in 1958 those are the questions you would have to answer.
00:01:07But of course not everyone would face those questions.
00:01:10The board of registrars had the sole authority to determine who got asked which literacy test questions and whose answers to those questions rendered them ineligible to vote.
00:01:20The idea was that black voters weren't being denied the right to vote based on race.
00:01:24That would be illegal.
00:01:26No, those voters just couldn't pass this literacy test.
00:01:30This isn't the plot of some kudzu and klansman gothic short story.
00:01:39This isn't a theoretical for first-year law students.
00:01:41This isn't some state department report on some tin pot dictatorship halfway around the world we can't pronounce.
00:01:46This is american history.
00:01:47This is really, really recent american history as in this lifetime for a lot of people american history.
00:01:53And the opening night speech at the national tea party convention this weekend proposed bringing the literacy test for voting back.
00:02:03And that proposal got a warm round of applause.
00:02:07>> Mostly because I think we do not have a civics literacy test before people can vote in this country, people who cannot even spell the word "vote" or say it in english put a committed socialist ideologue in the white house.
00:02:47The name is barack hussein obama.
00:02:51>> Whiplash wake-up point here is not that somebody with a record like tom tancredo would suggest something like this.
00:02:59He's made a living out of this schtik for sometime.
00:03:02What is important here is that a suggestion like that would be greeted with cheers from an american crowd.
00:03:05Hey, let's go back to the ways we used to keep black people from voting in this country.
00:03:10>> Mostly because I think we do not have a civics literacy test before people can vote in this country.
00:03:26>> Tom tancredo, what an idea!
00:03:29The crowd cheering the proposed return to literacy tests for voting.
00:03:36A the day after tom tancredo's speech, one of the convention's organizers was asked his response to this proposal.
00:03:45>> What do you think the message is when you're saying obama voters cannot pass a basic civics literacy test?
00:03:55It.
00:03:55>> Well, you know, tom tancredo gave a fantastic speech last night.
00:03:58I think he's an amazing politician.
00:04:01>> Amazing, yes.
00:04:02The tea party crowd that cheered the proposed return to literacy tests, literacy tests used for 70 years to keep black americans from voting, also hosted sarah palin as the event's keynote speaker.
00:04:14>> The republican party would be really smart to start trying to absorb as much of the tea party movement as possible because this is the future of our country, the tea party movement is the future of politics.
00:04:24>> The future.
00:04:27ON SEPTEMBER 12th, 1895, THE "New york times" reported on the state of south carolina's attempts to suppress the black vote.
00:04:36The article was titled "negroes must be barred.
00:04:39White supremacy demanded by the " among the things south carolina was considering to preserve white supremacy to prevent black people from voting was something they called the mississippi plan, a plan which, quote, requires an educational qualification consisting of the ability to read or understand any section of the constitution of the state.
00:05:00Such ability to be determined by the registration commissioners.
00:05:03The "new york times" explained at the time -- again, this is 1895 -- that the result would wholly abolish the negro majority and any immediate fear of it.
00:05:15And of course that's exactly what happened.
00:05:17Literacy tests were how african-americans were kept from voting in this country for some 70 years.
00:05:21This isn't ancient history.
00:05:23The alabama test I quoted from before?
00:05:25That's from 1965.
00:05:27These tests were one of the main targets of the voting rights act pushed by president lyndon johnson that same year.
00:05:37>> The harsh fact is that in many places in this country men and women are kept from voting simply because they are negroes.
00:05:49Every device of which human ingenuity is capable has been used to deny this right.
00:05:59He may be asked to recite the entire constitution.
00:06:04Or explain the most complex provisions of state law.
00:06:11And even a college degree cannot be used to prove that he can read and write.
00:06:22Well, the fact is that the only way to pass these barriers is to show a white skin.
00:06:28>> President johnson later signed into law a bill that he hoped would prevent what he called the systemic and ingenious discrimination of literacy tests for voting.
00:06:42There are african-americans who are members of congress today who were not during their lifetimes allowed to vote because of literacy tests for voting.
00:06:53Now the tea party movement is applauding a proposal to bring literacy tests for voting back and they are shocked and horrified to be called racist for doing so.
00:06:57Joining us now is harvard law professor charles ogletree director of harvard university's charles hamilton institute for race and justice.
00:07:07Thank you so much for joining us on the show tonight.
00:07:08>> Thank you, rachel.
00:07:09Happy to be with you.
00:07:09Happy new year.
00:07:10>> Thank you.
00:07:12Let me ask you first if I have fairly characterized the use of literacy tests in america as a tool for denying people the right to vote.
00:07:22>> You've only understated it.
00:07:23I mean, you talk about all types of poll taxes and literacy tests.
00:07:28My pastor, reverend adles had to tell the poll watcher how many marbles were in a jar, hundreds of marbles, and had to get the number right.
00:07:42All of these questions were designed to keep blacks from voting.
00:07:46But what tancredo said is remarkable.
00:07:49If you're talking about literacy tests, are you saying those people did not have the right to exercise one person, one vote?
00:07:55I think it's part of using the buzz words literacy I think it's part of thinking of using the buzz words, literacy test, that implies blacks because blacks have been denied that right.
00:08:09I think tom tancredo needs to read the constitution and think about what he means because there are a lot of black, white, and brown citizens all over america who have worked very hard to earn the right to vote and to tell them they are not capable, he is wrong.
00:08:16They lost the election in 2008.
00:08:17Get over it.
00:08:18It's time to live in 2010.
00:08:19>> On that issue of the legitimacy of president obama's election, about his, the questions about his eligibility for example.
00:08:25I was thinking about this today with reading all the reporting about how much the whole birtherism birth certificate issue won't go away for this president either.
00:08:35And I wonder if the idea is that it's not possible for barack obama to be president unless something's gone horribly wrong with the system that checks credentials and that okays people for voting and for high office.
00:08:52Is that in flekted by race?
00:08:55>> It is.
00:08:55And the reality is that president obama's done a remarkable job coming into a presidency with two wars and with the economy in the tank and had he's tried to overcome that with a lot of great plans and ideas like the stimulus package and even bailing out wall street which kept us from going into the great depression and trying to get health care.
00:09:12The reality is that there are people who still don't want him to be president because he's doing things they don't like.
00:09:18So race becomes a dividing issue but he is not going to let race become a burden or barrier to him accomplishing his goals as president.
00:09:24What's important about all of this, rachel, I think, is that the majority of americans, black and white, see that this president is trying to do a good job.
00:09:31They're not going to play the race baiting, and sarah palin on saturday I heard her talk about we don't want a professor of law who talks about the constitution and rights.
00:09:40We want the commander in chief.
00:09:41What's the difference?
00:09:43Isn't the law meaningful?
00:09:44Doesn't it mean something?
00:09:45Doesn't the constitution mean something?
00:09:47I think we need to go back to a 101 constitutional law test or civics test for folks who are going to talk about that for everybody to understand that we are a society who believes in equal justice under the law, one person, one vote.
00:10:02If you get more than, more votes than your opponent you win.
00:10:03It's over.
00:10:04Get over it and let's move forward.
00:10:06>> You think we could have a civics test for pundits and paid political speakers but not for voters?
00:10:11>> I think it's a little late for tancredo.
00:10:16I think voters have already told him he won't be in office again and I think he helped the republican party in some sense by letting people see if that's the extreme of what people are talking about, most democrats, most republicans are moderates.
00:10:29They're in the center.
00:10:32And tancredo is not going to get our vote.
00:10:35Two points.
00:10:36One, ignore him or overwhelm him with more speech that's rational, sensible, that has something to do with the constitution, with laws, with common sense, and all of that was left out of his comments this past weekend.
00:10:48>> I will tell you that my -- i think people could tell on the show on friday when I first talked about this and I spent the weekend reading up on the history of the means by which people were denied the right to vote in this country and got angrier and angrier about it.
00:10:59And I'm still mad about it now.
00:11:01I don't do my best work when I'm mad but I criticized the pancredo on friday and the crowd response to his speech as racist.
00:11:06That is not an epithet that i use often and not something i mean in an all purpose way.
00:11:10I mean it in a very specific way.
00:11:13People react to that allegation like you've thrown a bomb.
00:11:16Like there's no way to constructively consider whether a statement or proposal is really racist.
00:11:22Are we less able to talk about race and racism than we used to be or have we always been this hamstrung about it?
00:11:27>> I think we can talk about it more than ever before because we have a president who happens to be black and so it's an open dialogue and I'm glad we're having it because I think ultimately people will run out of things to say about barack obama about race.
00:11:40The question is does he have good judgment?
00:11:42He moving the country forward?
00:11:44He dealing with the issue of the economy?
00:11:48Is he trying to bring the soldiers home from these wars?
00:11:51Is he trying to get people jobs?
00:11:53And then race becomes irrelevant.
00:11:55I think that is the real key.
00:11:55Not whether we can talk about it but whether we can agree to disagree on certain things but continue to have the dialogue as well.
00:12:01Even thoughtful democrats and thoughtful progressive people, chris matthews, saying he forgot barack obama was black, and senator harry reid saying that he didn't speak the negro dialect, we need to do a lot of sort of race 101 across the political spectrum because it is the most controversial issue.
00:12:18I'm teaching a class now at the university of miami law school with over 40 students from all over the world and they understand that we're not in a a post racial america.
00:12:29We're in a very consciously race america.
00:12:31And we're going to learn how to make it a better place in the 21st century.
00:12:35>> Tom tancredo keeping us all in 101 as far as I'm concerned at this point.
00:12:39Professor charles ogletree, an eminent scholar of these and other matters, a real pleasure to have you on the show.
00:12:47It's an honor to have you here, sir.
00:12:48Thank you.
00:12:49>> Always my pleasure.
00:12:49>> Thank you.
00:12:50>>> If there is one candidate you would think would get the tea party seal of approval it would be the guy who was tea partying before tea partying was cool.
00:12:59Arch big government hater ron paul.
00:13:00Turns out, though, even ron paul has now got primary challengers getting tea partier than thou on him.
00:13:05That is next.
00:13:09Roasted chicken recipe?
00:13:10- Savory rice and lamb stew.- [ Barks ] You're right. Tonight isa beef stew kind of night.
00:13:15[ Announcer ]Beneful Prepared Meals.
00:13:17Another healthful,flavorful Beneful.
00:13:21auto!
00:13:22 finding everything okay?
00:13:25I work for a different insurance company.
00:13:27My auto policy's just getting a little too expensive.
00:13:29With progressive, you get the "name your price" option, so we build a policy to fit your budget.
00:13:34Wow! the price gun.
00:13:35 ♪♪
00:13:36wish we had this.
00:13:37We'd just tell people what to pay.
00:13:38Yeah, we're the only ones that do.
00:13:40I love your insurance!
00:13:42Bill?
00:13:43Tom?
00:13:44Hey! it's an office party!
00:13:46The freedom to name your price.
00:13:47Only from progressive.
00:13:48Call or click today.
00:14:12>>> Republican party chairman michael steele recently told a political audience in arkansas, quote, trust me, after taxes, a million dollars is not a lot of money.
00:14:21If the republican party ever decides to fire michael steele for saying stuff like that the democratic party should hire michael steele to keep saying stuff like that.
00:14:33Even as a forearm republican party chairman, the man would be political gold.
00:14:38More steele trap genius coming up.
00:14:41Theammunition she needs: Omnaris.
00:14:43(troops)OMNARIS! TO THE NOSE.
00:14:44(General)OMNARIS WORKS DIFFERENTLY Than many otherallergy medications.
00:14:47Omnaris fights nasalallergy symptoms ..
00:14:52Relieve those symptomswith omnaris.
00:14:54Side effects mayinclude headache, nosebleed andsore throat.
00:14:56Her nose isat ease.
00:14:58We havelift off.
00:15:00(General)REMEMBER OMNARIS! ASK YOUR DOCTOR.
00:15:01In the battle againstnasal allergy symptoms, omnaris combatsthe cause.
00:16:14Hi Hi ♪(whistling tune) ♪("Don't worry be happy")♪
00:17:05[ Crowd chanting ] >>> supporters of congressman ron paul back in december 2007, celebrating the 234th anniversary of the boston tea party with rallies across the nation and an online money bomb that raised millions of dollars for ron paul's presidential bid in 2008.
00:17:33Congressman ron paul's candidacy was arguably the spiritual godfather of what's now become the tea party movement.
00:17:40The current figurehead of the movement arguably is sarah palin.
00:17:44She's endorsed ron paul's son, rand, who was open-minded enough to make his senate campaign announcement several months ago on this very show.
00:17:53Rand paul, like his dad, is philosophically a libertarian but is running for office as a republican.
00:17:59Weirdly, congressman ron paul, himself, is now under attack from the very movement that he seemingly inspired.
00:18:06He's getting primaried in his district in texas by not one, not two, but three republican challengers, all of whom have associated themselves with the tea party movement by attending or organizing tea party rallies.
00:18:21They are each apparently hoping the anti-incumbent fervor of the tea party movement will sweep ron paul out of office.
00:18:27Yes, ron paul.
00:18:27The conservative candidate who in 2008 was able to draw more than 10,000 supporters away from the republican national convention with his libertarian message to attend his own shadow convention in minneapolis.
00:18:38He's now getting challenged by the supposedly libertarian- leaning conservatives that his presidential candidacy inspired.
00:18:46If they're not cool with ron paul, who are they cool with?
00:18:53Joining us now is dave weigel, the senior reporter for "the " he reported on this weekend's tea party convention in nashville.
00:19:03David, it's very nice to see you.
00:19:04Thanks for being here good to see you.
00:19:06Thanks.
00:19:07>> Let me just ask you the last question.
00:19:09If they're not cool with ron paul who are they cool with?
00:19:11I would have expected it to be a nice fit between the tea party movement and mr. paul.
00:19:14>> He's never been a good fit with these types of conservative activists because of the war issue.
00:19:20I kind of got misty-eyed looking at the old tea party videos.
00:19:22I was at one in 2007 in georgetown where a ron paul activist put things like federal reserve and unsound money on boxes and then jumped and smashed the boxes after they threw them on the floor.
00:19:35So they really did invent all of this stuff.
00:19:38But the tea party movement is more one of like conservative McCAIN, CONSERVATIVE PALIN Voters who are conservative on everything really that is main stream the republican party.
00:19:44They're more like jim demint than >> well, one of most fun things in all of american politics for the past year has been trying to figure out the tea party movement, all this incoherent anger and energy in this movement, trying to figure out what it really means in political terms.
00:20:07They do articulate their grievances as if they are libertarian grievances.
00:20:10But from your reporting, you're seeing that really what they're asking for is not libertarian policies?
00:20:14>> Economic policy I think they can attribute a little bit from him.
00:20:21But it's revealing whenever you hear the tea party movement is completely independent and completely one of populist anger that leaves out they're really pushing on an open door when it comes to the republican party.
00:20:30There is very little they say that the republican party disagrees with in the mainstream.
00:20:38Tom tancredo you played before, he was at the convention after he gave that speech and gave a little pep talk to the room on immigration policy and said, hey, you know, you guys did this really well before, back in 2006 you were melting the phones and stopping congress from passing immigration reform.
00:20:51Now, ron paul also happens to be against immigration amnesty, but those libertarian ideas that might be popular at the cato institute aren't popular with tea party activists.
00:21:02They're much more hard core conservatives who are really comfortable in the republican party.
00:21:07>> I feel where I'm getting to, and I am fired up about the tom tancredo call for the return to literacy tests thing not so much because he would do it because he does stuff like that all the time but that people would cheer for it.
00:21:21I guess I see the choose ron paul versus choose sarah palin test as kind of the litmus test for the politics of the tea party movement.
00:21:29That combined with cheering tancredo on this, I think, very racist appeal makes me feel like the modern tea party movement is an outgrowth of the angry people we saw frustrated during the McCAIN/PALIN CAMPAIGN SAYING Unpolitically correct things at rallies.
00:21:47Not an outgrowth of the tea parties before.
00:21:49>> Ron paul's movement, his presidential campaign was always much more positive and much more about these -- this basket of ideas that libertarians could implement that would fix the country.
00:22:02When he talked about getting back not constitution, getting back to the founders' vision, he was talking about getting american bases shut down, pulling out of foreign wars, abolishing social security, things like that.
00:22:19The palin version of tea party conservativism is a little bit less specific.
00:22:22It's a lot more slogany.
00:22:25It has -- you know, I guess you could write the talking points on your hand if you wanted to.
00:22:28And it's not so much about these well thought out historical solutions but there's a general idea of the constitution, and it just so happens to fit in with things that the republican party right now is very much into.
00:22:38So, yeah.
00:22:39There's less -- there are less difficult choices there.
00:22:42>> Dave weigel is a senior reporter for "the washington " thanks for your reporting on this continually and thanks for your time.
00:22:50Really appreciate it.
00:22:51>> Thank you so much.
00:22:52>>> As I said, rand paul has been a guest on this show in the past.
00:22:54Ron paul a number of times as well.
00:22:55We're hoping to have congressman ron paul on sometime soon to respond to the fact that he's getting more primary challengers now from the tea party movement than he's had any time recently in congress from anyone.
00:23:05All right.
00:23:07>>> Conservative critics say president obama is coddling terror suspects by reading them their rights.
00:23:13Those critics thereby blowing their own right to remain south on i-75, near exit 5.
00:23:20We're on it.
00:23:25Onstar, we may have that tahoe.
00:23:28Ok, I'll flash the lights.
00:23:29We got it. it's in the clear.
00:23:31I'm sending a signal to cut the power.
00:23:37We got him.
00:23:41 ross, the police have recovered your tahoe.
00:23:46temptationsby jell-o.
00:23:49A rich and airy treat.
00:23:53♪♪♪♪
00:23:54..
00:23:57..
00:24:01It's finally me o'clock.
00:24:04Enjoy it withmousse temptations.
00:24:08Three decadent flavors.60 calories.
00:24:11It's me o'clock.time for jell-o.
00:24:45Fresh and white.
00:24:45mine.
00:24:46It whitens and I bet your breath will still feel fresh after the movie.
00:24:48[ Female Announcer ] NEW CREST Extra white plus scope outlast.
00:24:51For a fresh breath feeling that lasts up to 5 times longer.
00:24:54Still fresh?
00:24:54Yip.
00:24:54I want to be mad but it's tough with that smile.
00:24:56[ Female Announcer ] CREST Extra white plus scope outlast.
00:26:51>>> Twice in the last week or so the top senate republican mitch McCONNELL HAS UNFLATTERINGLY Compared fbi agents interrogating the christmas day bomber to cnn's larry king.
00:27:04>> I mean larry king would have a more thorough interrogation of one of 4is witnesses than the christmas bomber had by the justice department.
00:27:15He was given a 50-minute interrogation, probably larry king has interrogated people longer and better than that.
00:27:21>> Casting no aspersions king, he always seemed like a nice man who is very good at his job, but WHAT DOES mitch McConnell have against the fbi?
00:27:31Has he got some specific beef with the fbi that he's going to take up in policy and legislation?
00:27:36Or is he just going to keep trashing fbi agents on television for political effect?
00:27:41This is the kind of thing that politicians usually end up having to apologize for.
00:27:46So far despite making the same crack twice in a five-day span, there's been no apology yet.
00:27:50I would warn you to set a google alert in anticipation but now that an ally of president obama's has said publicly that mitch McConnell should apologize to the fbi, I think we can be PRETTY SURE THAT MR. McCONNELL Will not apologize.
00:28:04>> Maybe if all those politicians stopped attacking THE FBI mitch McConnell likened the fbi to larry king interview.
00:28:15Maybe if they'd stop with the politics.
00:28:17>> Now that's cruel.
00:28:18>> No, I think he owes the fbi an apology.
00:28:19>> Former clinton chief of staff john podesta speaking there.
00:28:24He cochaired the obama/biden transition team and is one of many now pushing the gop in public for getting so much factually wrong.
00:28:30In the mad rush to politicize the christmas day bombing to try to hurt the president.
00:28:36>> Those fbi agents and others acted appropriately.
00:28:39And quite frankly I'm tiring of politicians using national security issues such as terrorism as a political football.
00:28:45They are going out there.
00:28:47They are unknowing of the facts and they're making charges and allegations that are not anchored in reality.
00:28:51On christmas night I called a number of senior members of congress.
00:28:55I SPOKE TO senators McConnell and bond.
00:28:58I spoke to representative boehner and hoekstra.
00:29:00I explained to them that he was in fbi custody, that abdulmutallab was in fact that he was cooperating at that point.
00:29:08They knew that in fbi custody means there is a process you follow as far as mirandizing and presenting him in front after of a imagine strai strat.
00:29:20None of those individuals raised any concerns with me at that point.
00:29:22They didn't say is he going into military custody?
00:29:25Is he going to be mirandized?
00:29:27>> That was white house counterterrorism expert speaking " senator bond has said he didn't understand a person in custody would naturally and as a matter of course be read their rights.
00:29:40Senator bond I should note here is actually a united states senator.
00:29:44The former counterterrorism adviser to president bush and president clinton before him, richard clarke also attacking the gop now for not grasping even the basic facts of how terrorism arrests and prosecutions work but still trying to use them to score political points.
00:29:56 clarke writing in "the new york daily news," quote, recent months have seen the party out of power picking fights over the conduct of our efforts against al qaeda, often with total disregard for the facts.
00:30:09It's been hard to escape the conclusion that the goal of these critics is to discredit the president's handling of terrorism for political advantage whether or not the administration is actually doing a good job.
00:30:19The gop talking point machine repeated by fox television commentators and others does not bother to learn the facts about terrorism before they leap to attacking the party in power's handling of the issue.
00:30:26They are wrong on the facts and they are wrong morally to attempt to make political gain on the damage inflicted by terrorism.
00:30:36 bush and bill clinton counterterrorism adviser richard clarke.
00:30:39Unless there be any doubt that the administration realizes that on this issue of terrorism it has caught its republican critics in the act of making stuff up and attacking their own policies, the president, himself, is going there.
00:30:53Here he was at a presuper bowl interview on cbs.
00:30:56>> We're not handling any of these cases any different than the bush administration handled them all through 9/11.
00:31:06They prosecuted 190 folks in these article iii courts, got convictions, and those folks are in maximum security prisons right now and there have been no escapes and it is a virtue of our system that we should be proud of.
00:31:23Some of the same critics of our approach have been employing this policy for years.
00:31:29>> Joining us now is nbc's chief foreign affairs correspondent andrea mitchell.
00:31:34Thank you so much for coming back on the show tonight and braving the snow to do so.
00:31:36>> You bet.
00:31:37No problem.
00:31:39>> Does it just feel like the administration and its allies are firing back hard against these attacks about the christmas day bomber or is this really a concerted effort?
00:31:47Am I connecting the appropriate do here?
00:31:50>> I think what's going on is that right after the massachusetts senate defeat for the democrats republicans realized they had a really good issue.
00:31:59The number one issue that scott brown mentioned in massachusetts was terror.
00:32:04It was terror, taxes, then health care.
00:32:06And I think they realized that they've got something going here and the administration has almost played into their hands with a series of steps that were not really well explained.
00:32:16And I think that is part of the problem.
00:32:18Part of the problem is it was christmas.
00:32:21People were given a two-minute briefing and in kind of a parallel world to the largely inadequate bush administration briefings that we know about to members of congress, democratic members of congress back then, i think they didn't want to tell very much nor did they want to go into a whole lot of detail nor was anyone really eagerly looking for information at that time partly because let's face it they were not on secure lines.
00:32:46Everyone was out of pocket.
00:32:48So this was a series of steps, accidents waiting to happen, where nobody was in a position where they could go to a secure room.
00:32:54Nobody was in washington.
00:32:57So part of it is accidental, coincidental.
00:32:59Part of it is deliberate because the republicans now smell blood.
00:33:03And the democrats certainly this white house has not been very good at explaining.
00:33:07You have this very unusual situation on "meet the press" where john brennan, a career intelligence official -- we don't know what political stripe he has if any.
00:33:19He actually went after republicans on the hill, people who might some day have to be confirming him if he were not in the white house and had a confirmable nomination, and you don't normally see this.
00:33:29This is a career guy who has worked in democratic and republican administrations at the cia and other places, and that was pretty unusual.
00:33:44Markis I isikoff were talking about this earlier today.
00:33:49A very unusual step for them to take.
00:33:51They feel that they have been maligned, misunderstood, and are being criticized for exactly what the bush administration did.
00:33:56>> You seemed last week on your show here on msnbc, we played the clip of your interaction with senator susan collins of maine talking about this issue and you seemed to somewhat sort of flabbergast her when you pointed out the procedures the obama administration followed now are the same the bush administration used in lots of other terrorism cases.
00:34:10I wonder if that sort of fact-based confrontation is pushing republicans to have to consciously position themselves as to the right of bush and cheney on terrorism now.
00:34:22>> Well, what they are arguing is that they should have been briefed, number one, that this interrogation was not handled properly.
00:34:28And in fact, they were given a little bit of a window there because dennis blair, the head of the director of national intelligence initially criticized the fbi for the way they handled it and then backed off that criticism.
00:34:39So there were a series of confusing signals from the administration, itself, indicating that there had been some mistakes made in this case.
00:34:47What they are now saying, the administration, is that there was 50 minutes of questioning, then they took him for medical care, and it was then that he clammed up and eventually had to be given his rights because he had been arrested here in the united states.
00:35:05There's plenty of evidence -- jane mayer, our colleague and friend, documents it brilliantly in "the new yorker" this week, plenty of evidence that there was a better track record with these civilian cases than with military commissions for people arrested during all of the bush years.
00:35:19So there's no question that they have gotten very good information.
00:35:22And I think the other frusting thing for the administration is they have not gotten out there just how cleverly they flew to nigeria after first blowing it when the father came in and went to the embassy and tried to talk about his son and, clearly, the agent on duty, the embassy officials probably all the way up to the ambassador did not pick up on those signals.
00:35:44So he should not have been on the fly list.
00:35:45He should have been stopped.
00:35:50He should -- his visa and access should have been checked way earlier.
00:35:53Those mistakes have been acknowledged.
00:35:54But then they went to nigeria, got the family involved, flew the family to detroit, and persuaded him to start talking and started getting very good actionable intelligence, they tell us.
00:36:05And so they're kind of angry that they're not getting credit for that.
00:36:10One other thing, rachel.
00:36:12I think this has been a perfect storm for the administration because they really did not properly handle the 9/11 terror trial proposal for new york city.
00:36:19They didn't notify the mayor, the police chief properly.
00:36:21They didn't work with the families.
00:36:22They didn't lay the ground work for that for bringing khalid sheikh mohammed to new york city.
00:36:37It's two things merged in people's mind, people like sarah palin who accuse the president of being soft on terror.
00:36:45>> Andrea mitchell, thanks very much again for joining us tonight.
00:36:47Appreciate it.
00:36:48>> You bet.
00:36:49>> Watch andrea mitchell every day on msnbc at 1:00 p.m.
00:36:51Eastern.
00:36:52Okay.
00:36:53>>> Still ahead michael steele shares his concept of wealth, which is every bit as michael steele as all of his other ideas.
00:36:59It's beautiful.
00:36:59Stay with us.
00:37:29] network, million.
00:37:302 million peopleare on sprint mobile broadband.
00:37:3331 Are streaming a salesconference from the road.
00:37:36154 Are tracking shipments on a train.
00:37:3933 Are iming on a ferry.
00:37:41And 1300 are secretly checking email on vacation.
00:37:46That's happening now.
00:37:47America's most dependable3g network.
00:37:49Bringing you the first and onlywireless 4g network.
00:37:51Right now get a free 3g/4gdevice for your laptop.
00:37:53 deaf, hard-of-hearing and people with speech disabilitiesppaccess www.sprintrelay.com.
00:39:14kitty!
00:39:14kitty!
00:39:16Oh, just come snuggle with momma!
00:39:18now at sears optical, get 2 pairs of glassesfor $99.99.
00:39:23With bifocals just$25 more per pair.
00:39:26Sears optical.don't miss a thing.
00:39:39>>> The latest republican solution for the budget crunch?
00:39:43Weaning.
00:39:48And the rachel maddow show does new orleans.
00:39:49Exclusive video of pure joy straight ahead.
00:39:51First a couple holy mackerel stories.
00:39:55Beginning with what happens if health reform doesn't pass?
00:39:58First of course a whole lot of democrats who have jobs in politics lose those jobs.
00:40:04Also the american economy keels over and dies.
00:40:07A nonpartisan accounting agency the center for medicare and medicaid services was tasked with crunching the numbers for what we spend on health care.
00:40:17What ne they came up with is a kick in the teeth.
00:40:22Last year health care spending grew more than it ever has since the government started keeping track of such things 50 years ago.
00:40:25It grew by $134 billion.
00:40:27That's the way things have been going since 1960.
00:40:33Up, up, up and up, most dramatically now.
00:40:36In 1960 health care spending was a grand total of about 5% of our gdp.
00:40:39By 1970 up to about 7%.
00:40:41By 1980, 9% of all the dollars we spent went to health care.
00:40:45By 1990 it was up to 12%.
00:40:47By 2000 almost 14%.
00:40:49And by last year our health care spending constituted more than 17% of our entire economic output as americans.
00:41:00We now spend one out of every $6 in our entire economy on health care.
00:41:05In ten years it's projected to be one in $5.
00:41:06Not one in six.
00:41:08One of every $5 we spend in our whole economy will be spent just on our own health care.
00:41:12And that's with not even covering everyone.
00:41:15Other industrialized countries cover everyone and have actual systems which control costs.
00:41:21The uk for example while not a perfect system is a full nationalized health system that covers everyone.
00:41:26For that they spend 7% of their gdp.
00:41:29We have no system.
00:41:30No way to control costs.
00:41:33And our health spending is 17% of our economy and growing.
00:41:38That's why reforming health care -- having an actual american health care system with cost controls, is a fiscally responsible thing to do.
00:41:51Or I think we could all agree it's at least fiscally insane not to do it.
00:41:54Case in point?
00:41:55One california insurance company anthem blue cross notified individual policy holders last week their premiums would be going up by as much as 39% this year.
00:42:03That's on top of an increase of premiums last year of as much as 68%.
00:42:07Unlike home and car insurance health insurance companies legally can jack up their rates whenever they want for as much as they want.
00:42:14But a rate increase this outrageous has attracted an investigation from the california insurance commissioner.
00:42:18Health and human services secretary kathleen sebelius is has also sent a letter to anthem blue cross asking them to justify the hikes.
00:42:27The company says it will respond once it receives the secretary's letter.
00:42:30Our calls to the company today were not returned.
00:42:32Perhaps they anticipated our planned questions about the timing of the rate hike.
00:42:36Anthem blue cross announced the second consecutive double digit rate hike right after announcing an eight fold increase in profit last quarter.
00:42:45We eagerly await whatever conceivable explanation they can come up with for this.
00:42:50We also eagerly await health reform.
00:43:51♪♪In depressed ♪♪
00:43:53♪♪ I was feeling at home ♪♪
00:43:54♪♪ had a poor credit score ♪♪
00:43:55♪♪ and the number would haunt me wherever I'd go ♪♪
00:43:57♪♪ thought I'd move to a place where my credit could stink ♪♪
00:43:58♪♪ and nobody would care ♪♪
00:44:01♪♪ I just wish that somebody had told me ♪♪
00:44:02 ♪♪
00:44:04 tell your friends, ♪♪
00:44:06 ♪♪
00:44:08♪♪ never mind, they've been singing our songs ♪♪
00:44:09♪♪ since we first showed up with our pirate ♪♪
00:44:11♪♪ if you're not into fake sword fights ♪♪
00:44:13♪♪ pointy slippers and green wool tights ♪♪
00:44:15♪♪ take a tip from a knight who knows ♪♪
00:44:16♪♪ free credit report dot com, let's go!
00:44:17♪♪
00:44:18 offer applies with enrollment in triple advantage part the sparkly flakes.
00:44:26The honey-baked bunches!
00:44:28The magic's in the mix.
00:44:29My favorite part? eating it.
00:44:31Honey bunches of oats.
00:44:32Taste the joy we put in every spoonful.
00:44:37Aren't absorbed properly unless taken with food.
00:44:41 it's different -- it's calcium citrate, so it can be absorbed with or without food.
00:44:47Also available in small, easy-to-swallow petites.
00:44:50Citracal.
00:44:56>>> 106 Million people watch the super bowl on tv.
00:45:00Kent jones watched it on tv in a bar in new orleans.
00:45:03With a camera on the crowd.
00:45:04It was an experience he describes as historically insane.
00:45:08Stay tuned for that.
00:46:43>>> In a face-to-face recent appearance with former congressman harold ford, the republican party chairman michael steele was attacking president obama's decision to let the bush tax cuts expire for the top 2% of earners.
00:46:56Mr. steele then said this.
00:46:58Quote, trust me, after taxes, a million dollars is not a lot of money.
00:47:03The 98% of americans who make less than $250,000 a year will be interested to learn that from the republican party chairman.
00:47:12Of further interest to those people will be the republican new/old proposal for social security.
00:47:15The ranking republican on the house budget committee paul ryan of wisconsin is now reproposing president bush's 2005 proposal president bush's 2005 proposal to privatize social security.
00:47:27Which would I got to tell you be a great idea if the stock market always went up.
00:47:30Does the stock market always go up?
00:47:33Meanwhile, congresswoman michele bachman this weekend offered this idea about social security and said, quote, basically what we have to do is wean everybody else off.
00:47:43And wean everybody off because we have to take those unfunded net liabilities off our bank sheet.
00:47:47We can't do it.
00:47:49So we just have to be straight with people.
00:47:53Will there be wean panels to decide who starves in poverty and who survives?
00:47:58Democrats have now had the bright idea of forcing republicans to actually vote on these republican proposals.
00:48:04Pass popcorn, hide grandma.
00:48:06Joining us now is democratic congressman anthony weiner.
00:48:12Congressman, thanks for coming back on the show.
00:48:13>> Thank you.
00:48:15Is this what they meant about weaned, you get wiener proposal?
00:48:21>> You were teased on the play yard.
00:48:23I feel like we're having a flashback to the way we first met, which is you forcing republicans to take an awkward vote on killing medicare.
00:48:30Is this the same kind of politics?
00:48:31>> Yes, but this is to the nth degree.
00:48:36 ryan's proposals represent the republican budget proposals.
00:48:40This is the way they propose to this handle the challenges that we face.
00:48:45At least they're coming out from where they're hiding, we're against social security, we want to privatize it, against medicare, want to give people vouchers.
00:48:53So a third of the vouchers go to health insurance company profits rather than health care.
00:48:57I think they should have to answer and I think the president did a smart thing by taking these see seriously.
00:49:03I think they make no sense and most people who get the benefits will say that they don't.
00:49:07But they represent the republican mainstream thinking.
00:49:09This is not a fringe movement.
00:49:11This is what the budget committee ranking member says he wants to do.
00:49:15>> It seems like the political maneuver is to say however you think the president is doing under president obama and democratic majorities, that's one thing.
00:49:24This isn't a referendum on that.
00:49:26This is a choice between the democrats are offering and what the republicans.
00:49:33That leaves it to the democrats.
00:49:35>> Remember what we did.
00:49:37We went through eight years where arguably a lot of the decisions were not made.
00:49:40We were funding things without paying for them.
00:49:42Then we went into a campaign where the president said to his credit and democrats said we're going to treat this like adults, make tough decisions.
00:49:49A lot of them are unpopular.
00:49:51Now at least we're not going to be boxing with ourselves against the idea.
00:49:54We're going to talk about other people's proposals and I think the republicans will have to decide.
00:49:59I can't wait to see if the republicans vote for these republican proposals, because i can't imagine that there's a majority of them or a large number of them that believes in the notion that if we invest in the social security trust fund in the stock market that this we would be a lot better off.
00:50:12>> Especially given what we've been through.
00:50:15Congressman ryan says he's willing to lose his job over his ideas.
00:50:18He sees this as a position of political bravery.
00:50:22Is there a libertarian no government streak in the republican party that is where they might get a lot of votes for this?
00:50:29>> Republicans never liked social security and they have been trying to do this type of thing for a while.
00:50:33The same is true of medicare.
00:50:35There's something implicit in this whole conversation about the fear of government-run health care that logically extended means you don't like medicare.
00:50:41But what they can't get away with any longer is criticizing democrats for attacking medicare when we're trying to save it or say they're the more responsible protecters of the interest of taxpayers when they want to invest large amounts of our trust fund in the stock market.
00:50:57They can't get away with it anymore.
00:50:59>> One last question on a totally different matter.
00:51:02In congressman john murtha passed away today.
00:51:04I know you knew him very well.
00:51:07Do you have any reflections on his paging?
00:51:09>> A remarkable man, if you think about recent americans 'civic life had a remarkable influence.
00:51:14He was a hawk, someone who is the defense appropriations chairman who came out relatively early on and said the iraq war was a mistake and wasn't working.
00:51:23He automatically overnight changed the debate.
00:51:26Beyond that, he was someone from a different era who was a genuinely nice, decent man.
00:51:31It was hard to find anyone in congress who didn't love and admire him.
00:51:35I'm going to miss him very much.
00:51:36>> Good to see you.
00:51:37>>> Coming up on "countdown," keith talks to harry shearer about the importance of the saints win for new orleans.
00:51:45Kent jones was in new orleans for the game and the massive party that ensued afterwards still ringing in kent's head tdd# 1-800-345-2550 is now $8.95.
00:51:55Tdd# 1-800-345-2550 no matter your account balance, tdd# 1-800-345-2550 often you trade or how ..
00:51:58Tdd# 1-800-345-2550 you pay what they pay what everyone pays: $8.95.
00:52:02Tdd# 1-800-345-2550 and you still get all the help and support tdd# 1-800-345-2550 you expect from schwab.
00:52:07Tdd# 1-800-345-2550 millions of investors.
00:52:08One price.
00:52:09Tdd# 1-800-345-2550 at charles schwab investors rule.
00:52:12Tdd# 1-800-345-2550 are you ready to rule?
00:52:18hey!
00:52:18hey!
00:52:18I was just in town for a few days, and I was wondering if I could say hi to the doctor.
00:52:21Is he in?
00:52:22He's in copenhagen.
00:52:22Oh, well, that's nice.
00:52:23But you can still see him!
00:52:24You just said ..
00:52:25Copenhagen.
00:52:27Come on!
00:52:28That's pretty far.
00:52:30Doc, look who's in town.
00:52:32Ellen!
00:52:33Copenhagen?
00:52:33Cool, right?
00:52:35Vacation.
00:52:35But still seeing patients.
00:52:36Oh.
00:52:37[ whispering ] Workaholic.
00:52:38I heard that.
00:52:39She said it.
00:52:40..
00:52:40[ Female Announcer ] The new office.
00:52:42See it. live it.
00:52:43Share it.
00:52:44On the human network.
00:52:46Cisco.
00:53:18temptationsby jell-o.
00:53:21♪♪♪♪
00:53:26three decadent flavors.60 calories.
00:53:29It's me o'clock.time for jell-o.
00:54:33I'm just a skeptic so I don't necessarily believe that anything is going to work but I was like, hey, this actually works.
00:54:38(announcer)ONLY ROGAINE FOAM Is shown toregrow hair in 85% of guys.
00:54:42I'll check it out and I'm like, nice.
00:54:44(announcer)ROGAIN FOAM.
00:54:45Stop losing.start gaining.
00:55:05>>> We did something uncharacteristic on this show.
00:55:07On friday night we went all the way to new orleans because of this super bowl.
00:55:11As it turned out, super bowl was the most watched show in television history.
00:55:20Bigger nan the finale of masche.
00:55:2565 Million people tuned in to watch the colts, but not all 5 million people had the same experience.
00:55:32Our own kent jeauxnse made the life affirming experience to stay in new orleans to watch the game with the who dat nation.
00:55:38Kent, you win!
00:55:40>> You said the words historically insane earlier.
00:55:44It was!
00:55:45It so was.
00:55:46I was in this incredibly packed bar in the french quarter called one-eyed jacks.
00:55:52The place went off.
00:55:54Unbelievable 40 years of frustration gone.
00:55:56And then they started cranking acdc's "it's a long way to the top if you want to rock 'n roll," which I did clearly.
00:56:03People were dancing and screaming "who dat," and that was just me.
00:56:07Unbelievable!
00:56:10Then everybody pointed out on the street, and we squeezed our way into bourbon street.
00:56:16More screaming, high-fiving stranger, who dat, who dat.
00:56:20Music going absolutely everywhere.
00:56:22Total mayhem for a long way in the distance.
00:56:26But I did get to actually talk to some really happy who dats afterwards.
00:56:32Really happy.
00:56:33>> I've been here since '84, been born and raised here.
00:56:35This means everything!
00:56:36>> This is incredible.
00:56:42It's not your daddy's saints.
00:56:42Super bowl champs.
00:56:43[ Cheering ] >> this whole town has been behind this team.
00:56:50>> It's better than mardi gras.
00:56:52This is the saints' mardi gras.
00:56:53>> When are you going back to work, like maybe march?
00:56:58>> No, april.
00:57:00>> We call this the scream umbrella.
00:57:02Ready?
00:57:02One, two, three!
00:57:04>> All of this is amazing that it happened during mardi gras.
00:57:09>> That's like the regularly scheduled craziness.
00:57:11So they had that too, like this, right?
00:57:13The incredible floats and people are throwing beads, and there is likelihooded riders, and this incredible costumes that they have.
00:57:21And there I am trying to get beads because I need beads.
00:57:24That's the thing I need.
00:57:26Throw me plastic stuff.
00:57:27And then there was a dog mardi gras that I went to.
00:57:30Lots of saints outfits.
00:57:33The crew of barkus.
00:57:35And then here is what happened.
00:57:36I got slobbered on.
00:57:39Oh, yeah, dog slobber!
00:57:41So obviously a wonderful, great time.
00:57:43There was actually a dog there called pooh brees.
00:57:53New orleans does absolutely everything.
00:57:55They're just having so much fun with it.
00:57:56My favorite guy was this guy, and he called himself -- breesu
00:13:48♪♪ ♪♪
00:13:52[ Male Announcer ] You can get a lot of water where you least expect it.
00:13:56Like in here.
00:13:57This detergent has this much cleaning ingredients.
00:14:00The rest is water.
00:14:00But with tide, you get more cleaning ingredients -- more than twice as much.
00:14:07♪♪ ♪♪
00:14:07so that you get an outstanding tide clean.
00:14:11♪♪ ♪♪
00:14:14tide. you pay for detergent.
00:14:14You get more detergent.
00:37:41what's it's your blades pal ah man, I should have known.
00:37:44Even the best blades get worn down.
00:37:46When that happens, it's not as comfortable, see?
00:37:48When the strip turns white ..
00:37:50For a smoother ride.
00:37:51(announcer)GILLETTE FUSION. FRESH BLADE.
00:37:53More comfortable shave.
00:44:19Hi, may I help you?
00:44:20Yes, I hear progressive has lots of discounts on car insurance.
00:44:24Can I get in on that?
00:44:25Are you a safe driver?
00:44:26Yes.
00:44:27Discount!
00:44:28Do you own a home?
00:44:29Yes.
00:44:30Discount!
00:44:31Are you going to buy online?
00:44:33Yes!
00:44:33Discount!
00:44:34Isn't getting discounts great?
00:44:35Yes!
00:44:38There's no discount for agreeing with me.
00:44:40Yeah, I got carried away.
00:44:42Happens to me all the time.
00:44:43Helping you save money -- now, that's progressive.
00:44:46Call or click today.
00:52:45guest page.
00:52:47Hi, ellen!
00:52:48Hi, ellen!
00:52:48Hi, ellen!
00:52:48Hi, ellen!
00:52:49We're going on a field trip to china!
00:52:51WOW. [ chuckles ] When I was a kid, we -- we would just go to the -- the farm.
00:52:56[ cow moos ] [ laughter ] No, seriously, where are you guys going?
00:53:01Ni hao!
00:53:02Ni hao!
00:53:02Ni hao!
00:53:02Ni hao!
00:53:03Ni hao!
00:53:03Ni hao!
00:53:03Ni hao!
00:53:04Ni hao!
00:53:05Ni hao!
00:53:05Ni hao!
00:53:05Ni hao!
00:53:06Ni hao!
00:53:07[ Female Announcer ] The new classroom.
00:53:09See it. live it.
00:53:09Share it.
00:53:11On the human network.
00:53:12Cisco.
00:53:15signof cold...
00:53:15( sneezing ) I didn't takeZicam Cold Remedy...
00:53:20But I did.
00:53:21Zicam reduces the durationof a cold.
00:53:24( sneezing ) No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no...
00:53:26Can you do it by 3:00 ? Yes, I can.
00:53:28How about 2:00 ? Hmm...
00:53:30( sneezing ) ( moaning ) Get over your cold faster.
00:53:38Now try new throat-soothingLiqui-Loz and great-tasting Zavors.
mReplay LiveDash is a registered trademark of mReplay Corporation. The information provided with mReplay LiveDash is for informational purposes only. For more information, please see our terms of use. The network logos used on mReplay LiveDash are registered trademarks of those respective companies, including Fox, NBC, CBS, PBS, ABC, FX, TNT, ESPN, ESPN2, TBS, USA, MTV, VH1, Spike, A&E, Bravo, AMC, TLC, Animal Planet, ABC Family, Cartoon Network, Disney, CNN, CNBC, Fox News, MSNBC, Comedy Central, Entertainment, TV Land and Oxygen. These networks, Fox, NBC, CBS, PBS, ABC, FX, TNT, ESPN, ESPN2, TBS, USA, MTV, VH1, Spike, A&E, Bravo, AMC, TLC, Animal Planet, ABC Family, Cartoon Network, Disney, CNN, CNBC, Fox News, MSNBC, Comedy Central, Entertainment, TV Land and Oxygen, are not affiliated with mReplay LiveDash, or mReplay Corporation.